Sale 22AM01 | Lot 1141

Philadelphia Interest: Pair of American Silver Two-Handled Vases of Historic Importance

Catalogue: American Paintings, Furniture & Decorative Arts
Philadelphia Interest: Pair of American Silver Two-Handled Vases of Historic Importance

Lot Details

Lot 1141
Philadelphia Interest: Pair of American Silver Two-Handled Vases of Historic Importance
Thomas Fletcher and Sidney Gardiner, Philadelphia, 1832
Each of urn-form, the bodies engraved with bands of vertical leaves, the handles formed as dolphins with entwined tails, on a foliate pedestal foot. The inner rim of each engraved with presentation inscription "Thomas Biddle to His Brother James August 26, 1831." Heights 8 1/4 inches, total approximately 43 ounces.

Thomas Biddle (1790- 1831) was one of ten children born to prominent Philadelphian Charles Biddle and his wife Hannah. Thomas accomplished quite a bit in his relatively short life - heroism in the war of 1812 where he was wounded twice, and professional success as army paymaster during American expansion west, appointed to that post in St Louis in 1820. Thomas married Ann Mullanphy, daughter of Missouri's first millionaire in St. Louis in 1823, and eventually became the director of the St. Louis branch of the Bank of the United States, and began to wade into political waters. It is the infamous result of his public dealings for which Thomas Biddle is now most consequently known.

In 1831, Missouri Congressman Spencer Darwin Pettis criticized the policies championed by Thomas's older brother Nicholas, President of the Second Bank of the United States. The attack became scathingly personal and boiled over into the infamous skirmish. In July, Thomas physically attacked Pettis with a cowhide whip while the latter lay in bed recovering from a sickness at a St. Louis hotel. After a few weeks of recuperation following the assault, Pettis challenged Biddle to a duel, which Biddle accepted. As the challenged party, Thomas chose the weapons (pistols) and the distance (an unusually close five feet) for the event. Biddle was nearsighted and some contemporaries looked to that as justification for the short distance. At this distance the parties would be so close that their pistols may actually have overlapped. Others saw it as a sure way for both men to die, and therefore as a kind of bluff by Biddle, giving cover to Pettis to call off the confrontation while still maintaining honor. In the end Pettis called the bluff, if that's what it was, and the place was set for the duel - a sandbar in the middle of the Mississippi River appropriately named Bloody Island. It was scheduled for 5:00pm on August 26, 1831.

With money, a storied Philadelphia pedigree, a taste for the finer things, and the end of his life almost certainly the outcome of the duel, Biddle sought to memorialize himself for his family. By way of his will drawn up just the night before the duel, he instructed his wife to approach the prominent Philadelphia silversmiths Thomas Fletcher and Sidney Gardiner to make ten memorial vases to be given to Thomas Biddle's siblings and to his wife's siblings. Fletcher and Gardiner were one of America's most prominent silversmiths in the early Republic period, specializing in work of "unprecedented quality and grandeur." They solidified their fame soon after their 1811 move from Boston to Philadelphia by designing and creating naval trophies to commemorate battles won by Isaac Hull and William Bainbridge, commanders of the USS Constitution during the war of 1812. Their presentation silver work, for which there was no precedent in America's history of silversmithing, incorporated bold and patriotic themes, often on a grand scale, coupled with unimpeachable workmanship. The cost was a substantial $60 for each vase - more than the average yearly salary for Americans. The pair of calyx krater-form vases presently offered, directly descended in the family for almost 200 years from the Christine Biddle Wainwright collection, are each inscribed to Thomas's brother, James, himself a naval veteran of the War of 1812, and are dated August 26, 1831 (the day of the fateful duel). Each features flaring anthemion-decorated rims, stylized acanthus ornamentation to the bodies and bases, and handles of finely worked intertwined dolphin tails. Such pieces would have been the height of fashion for the day.

The duel proceeded as scheduled, at 5:00 pm on the 26th with hundreds watching from the shoreline of St. Louis. Both Biddle and Pettis fired a single shot, and each suffered a fatal wound. Before being carried off the island each man was overheard forgiving the other for the altercation. Spencer Pettis died the day after the confrontation, Thomas Biddle three days later, on August 29th, 1831.

The Magazine Antiques article "Major Thomas Biddle's Silver Vases" from January 1979 gives great detail to the history of each vase to that date. The author answers the question as to why the two vases offered here are each inscribed to James, yet records stated that each sibling was to receive just a single vase. They note that on his death in 1848, James left his silver including his vase to his sister Ann Biddle Hopkinson (1800-1863). At some point later in their history, the inscription from James's vase was copied onto the one presented to Ann.

Of the ten urns originally commissioned, a pair can still be found at the Biddle family seat Andalusia, outside Philadelphia; another was included in the exhibition "Silversmiths to the Nation: Thomas Fletcher and Sidney Gardiner, 1808-1842," which premiered at the Metropolitan Museum of Art in 2007, and later traveled to Winterthur Museum & Country Estate, in Delaware. The Magazine Antiques recorded the locations of five of the vases, including the current pair to 1979.



C The Christine Biddle Wainwright Collection

Estimate: $7,000 - $10,000
Sold for $59,850 (includes buyer's premium)

Additional Notes & Condition Report

Each generally good condition overall; the vases vary slightly in size with the handle placement differing; slight denting to rims; each clearly marked up inside foot; inscriptions good and legible; one urn slightly heavier than the other


Any condition statement is given as a courtesy to a client, is an opinion and should not be treated as a statement of fact and Doyle New York shall have no responsibility for any error or omission. Please contact the specialist department to request further information or additional images that may be available.

No condition report? Click here to request one.

Estimate: $7,000 - $10,000
Sold for $59,850 (includes buyer's premium)

Ask the Specialist Track Lot
Catalogue Info

American Paintings, Furniture & Decorative Arts

Wed, May 04, 2022 at 10am EDT
View All Lots